First of all, great work by Benny!
Personally I wouldn't go for the red one. It's not I don't like the colour or the layout, but because it eventually may look too similar to Julia's, which already has red as main colour. It's just a detail, but hey, you wanted to hear what we think, lol.
The current website has lots of blue, so I'm not going for that one either. If you decide to 'pimp' (or in normal language, refresh) the whole thing, it's best to choose a different colour than what you currently have. I like the purple/green one most, Walt wrote down the reason why. The combination makes the eyes want to 'scan' the whole page.
Font/size look good. Obviously, don't forget to mention that all the new ShandaFay members get access to the other 12 VNA girls as well. Despite the fact we all seem to know, many newbies who are told, respond with:
Huh? Really? Cool! I know, sounds weird, but after being here for almost 5 months now (yay!) and welcoming new people to the network, I noticed that comment a few times ... And I assume we're gonna get a new, short introduction clip on the homepage?
Things look good so far, I'm definitely looking forward to the new and improved
http://www.filthycuteonline.com, version 2012!
Life is not measured by the number of breaths we take, but by the moments that take our breath away.
all the time Benny put into these to try to give me something to think about. 
and Torp!
